Would like to GM

Enjoyed the game, puzzle was a good change of pace. enemies where too easy, single targets often are lacking challenge unless the CR is quite a bit above the party. the traps needed more punishment, damage or ability damage or something that makes them worth avoiding.

that being said
too short, did not meet minimum requirements so I cannot pass this for that reason alone.

The good
- fun
- puzzles, traps, etc (more than just combat)

The bad
- timing
- difficulty (too easy, especially combat)
- the FIAT poison - nearly universal that fort negates poisons with a high enough roll.



It would have been a pass if it was longer, one more combat or more difficult combat would have done it.

Enjoyed the game, fun concept. Suggestion were given to increase the challenge as it was overall in the players favor. biggest criticism was the table stats being heavy on gold and light on XP. I do not believe that combats are too easy at level 1, I am of the belief they're either too easy or too hard at level 1 so I do not penalize his combat for being rolled over by color spray.

I and the players did enjoy the game and hope to see the same concept more refined for more fun games.

Pass

[insert ice cream pun here ]

Lurk Bonemeant, Buck Plankchest, Lillith, Reez, and Lyrek were hired by Hannibal Creme to help restore his ice cream factory
after arriving there the found serveral ice cream monsters, and realized the most effective way to dispatch of them was with
their ice cream scoopers! after dispatching all of the little ones, The Found a Giant Neapolitan Ice cream Monster it was a
Cold Hard monster to take down, but their teamwork made quick work of the monster and then helped Hannibal get his business back in action!


1750 exp 2100 gp

dm reward : ullr

[750 gp] wand of floating disk (CL 1)

[375 gp] wand of create water (CL 1)

[25 gp] arcane scroll of cause fear (CL 1)

[50 gp] potion/oil of endure elements (CL 1)

[25 gp] divine scroll of divine favor (CL 1)

[50 gp] potion/oil of invigorate (CL 1)

[375 gp] divine scroll of water walk (CL 5)

[375 gp] wand of create water (CL 1)

[2,000 gp] manacles of cooperation [no external clues]

[300 gp] potion/oil of slipstream (CL 3)

[25 gp] arcane scroll of charm person (CL 1)

[750 gp] wand of mount (CL 1)

[50 gp] potion/oil of erase (CL 1)

[150 gp] arcane scroll of haunting mists (CL 3)

[50 gp] potion/oil of enlarge person (CL 1)

[50 gp] potion/oil of keen senses (CL 1)

[375 gp] arcane scroll of major image (CL 5)

[300 gp] potion/oil of barkskin (CL 3)

[25 gp] potion/oil of purify food and drink (CL 1)

[50 gp] potion/oil of enlarge person (CL 1)

[50 gp] potion/oil of magic weapon (CL 1)

[150 gp] divine scroll of cure moderate wounds (CL 3)

[150 gp] divine scroll of undetectable alignment (CL 3)

[50 gp] potion/oil of hide from undead (CL 1)

[50 gp] divine scroll of bless water (CL 1)

[50 gp] potion/oil of magic weapon (CL 1)

[25 gp] potion/oil of light (CL 1)

[50 gp] potion/oil of shillelagh (CL 1)

[25 gp] divine scroll of liberating command (CL 1)

[25 gp] arcane scroll of ray of sickening (CL 1)

[25 gp] arcane scroll of mage armor (CL 1)

[25 gp] arcane scroll of ray of enfeeblement (CL 1)

[25 gp] potion/oil of resistance (CL 1)

[25 gp] divine scroll of keen senses (CL 1)

[25 gp] divine scroll of shield of faith (CL 1)

[25 gp] potion/oil of light (CL 1)

TOTAL PASS

Overall he gets a pass on bladeandbow.boards.net/thread/3496/pirates-treasure since sharp didn't link it. He made changes to the encounters based on part performance, he had interesting environmental effects in the last room, although other encounters could have benefited from some as well. Had a solid grasp on all the basic rules and was able to keep the party on track and the session moving fairly well.